The Beefeater Steak House

Very disappointed with the food and service. Took over an hour to get our food. When it arrived it wasn't very good. Suggest going to the Keg instead.

Good staff and great food

I would go to the Beefeater over the Keg any day. Always a great meal. Recently went to the Keg and had a very cold meal and when mentioned to the manager we got $6 off a $200 tab. Never a bad experience at The Beefeater.

Late dinner. Great service and value. Excellent food and atmosphere.

Everything was totally awesome. Really enjoyed the beef eater.

I ordered the steak and lobster, it was $53 including salad bar. Lobster was overboiled and was rubbery. My steak I was assured by the waitress would be a medium rare as I always ask for a rare because by the time it gets to the table it is a medium rare as it should. When I received mine however it was more like a medium to a medium well. Not very happy, I have had better meals at the pub for $10.

I was quite upset about paying $120+ for 2 people for such a mediocre meal I had to call the manager and at least let him know. The manager was very rude and kept blaming me for not sending my order back, well how so when the waitress didnt come back 20 mins later when I was already ready to leave. Such a disgrace this place used to be a high end establishment but after this I don't think I will ever return.

The Beefeater has been a family favorite for special events for over a decade, however, in recent years we have been going less and less and now I am unsure if we will be going back.

It mainly comes down to the food. The Beefeater has been around for quite some time, and in the decade we have been going there, the food hasn't changed one bit. Now this isn't necessarily bad, but the food now is very dated. The veggies you get with a steak meal are bland and uninspired lacking any thought or creativity, and the stuffed potato is in the same. The steak is decent, however it lacks any resemblance of seasoning, the only saving grace is the nice grill flavor you get from their broiler. I think the best way to summarize the food is it feels like your grandmothers cooking, which isn't the worst, however I would never pay 40$ for my grandmothers food.

The only reason myself, and potentially others as well, keep going back is simply for the nostalgia. We've been going here for years and it use to be our special place. However as of recently there are simply better places to go in town. Many other restaurants have modernized their menus over the past few years and simply offer better constructed meals that do not have a 40$+ price point. While I hate to draw comparison, if you are looking for a 40$+ meal, The Keg is simply a better alternative.

There is still hope for the Beefeater, their steak is definitely unique and that is a saving grace, but they really need to take a look at the rest of their menu and add some character to make myself, my family, and others turn.

Nice decor and the service was really good but the steaks are thin and one of our party had to send hers back because it was way under done. Presentation was average at best.

Classy joint with great food and nice family friendly environment. We will be back!

Always great food and great service! Nice atmosphere too as it is the kind of place that you can actually have a conversation!